Philosophy in Progress

Share this post

Berdyaev on the Moral Source of Atheism

williamfvallicella.substack.com

Berdyaev on the Moral Source of Atheism

The cause of theism is not well-served by the caricaturing of atheists as all of the same stripe.

William F. Vallicella
Oct 17, 2022
Share this post

Berdyaev on the Moral Source of Atheism

williamfvallicella.substack.com

There are respectable forms of atheism. The atheist needn't be a rebellious punk stuck in intellectual adolescence, swamped by sensuality, and given to self-idolatry.  

Nicholas Berdyaev, The Destiny of Man (Harper Torchbooks, 1960, tr. Natalie Duddington, p. 24):

Thanks for reading Philosophy in Progress! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

It is precisely the traditional theology that leads good men, inspired by moral motives, to atheism. The ordinary theological conception of freedom in no way saves the Creator from the responsibility for pain and evil.  Freedom itself is created by God and penetrable by Him down to its very depths. In His omniscience, ascribed to Him by positive theology, God foresaw from all eternity the fatal consequences of freedom with which He endowed man. He foresaw the evil and suffering of the world which has been called into being by His will and is wholly in His power; He foresaw everything, down to the perdition and everlasting torments of many. And yet He consented to create man and the world under those terrible conditions. This is the profound moral source of atheism.

I read Berdyaev's The Beginning and the End in the summer of 1970.  The following autumn I committed myself to philosophy as my vocation. The Russian personalist moved me deeply at the time, but then other philosophical interests and concerns took over. It is wonderful to be reading him again some 50 years later.  If this existentialist is a bit on the febrile side, he at least avoids the empty intellectual gamesmanship of the analytic logic choppers  whose philosophical activity bespeaks their spiritual vacuity.  The task of the true philosopher is to combine rigor and Wissenschaftlichkeit with spiritual depth. Plato and Spinoza come to mind. We lesser lights are not quite up to the task, but we ought to take such luminaries as guides and tutelary spirits. 

Berdayev 1

Addendum

Some of us are old enough to remember seeing Bishop Fulton J. Sheen on television.  His message below is effectively answered by Berdyaev above. The cause of theism is not well-served by the caricaturing of atheists as all of the same stripe.  There are saints and scamps on both sides of the theological divide.

Fulton Sheen on atheism

Thanks for reading Philosophy in Progress! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Share this post

Berdyaev on the Moral Source of Atheism

williamfvallicella.substack.com
TopNew

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 William F. Vallicella
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing